57 intentioned, they either back-fire or are already obsolete |
57 intentioned, they either back-fire or are already obsolete |
58 because of newer technologies. The result is that the world of |
58 because of newer technologies. The result is that the world of |
59 ``privacy'' looks a little bit like the old Wild |
59 ``privacy'' looks a little bit like the old Wild |
60 West---lawless and mythical. |
60 West---lawless and mythical. |
61 |
61 |
|
62 We would have hoped that after Snowden, Western governments |
|
63 would be a bit more sensitive and enlightned about the topic |
|
64 of privacy, but this is far from the truth. Ross Anderson |
|
65 wrote the following in his blog about the approach taken in |
|
66 the US to lessons learned from the Snowden leaks and contrasts |
|
67 this with the new snooping bill that is considered in the UK |
|
68 parliament: |
|
69 |
|
70 \begin{quote}\it |
|
71 ``The comparison with the USA is stark. There, all three |
|
72 branches of government realised they'd gone too far after |
|
73 Snowden. President Obama set up the NSA review group, and |
|
74 implemented most of its recommendations by executive order; |
|
75 the judiciary made changes to the procedures of the FISA |
|
76 Court; and Congress failed to renew the data retention |
|
77 provisions in the Patriot Act (aided by the judiciary). Yet |
|
78 here in Britain the response is just to take Henry VIII powers |
|
79 to legalise all the illegal things that GCHQ had been up to, |
|
80 and hope that the European courts won't strike the law down |
|
81 yet again.'' |
|
82 \end{quote} |
|
83 |
|
84 \noindent Unfortunately, also big organisations besides |
|
85 governments seem to take an unenlightened approach to privacy. |
62 For example, UCAS, a charity set up to help students with |
86 For example, UCAS, a charity set up to help students with |
63 applying to universities in the UK, has a commercial unit that |
87 applying to universities in the UK, has a commercial unit that |
64 happily sells your email addresses to anybody who forks out |
88 happily sells your email addresses to anybody who forks out |
65 enough money for bombarding you with spam. Yes, you can opt |
89 enough money for bombarding you with spam. Yes, you can opt |
66 out very often from such ``schemes'', but in case of UCAS any |
90 out very often from such ``schemes'', but in case of UCAS any |